How we score

Every score shows its work.

Every product gets a score from 0 to 100 for each concern it claims to help, because a serum can be brilliant for dark spots and useless for firmness. Each score answers four questions: how strong the evidence is, whether there's enough in the bottle, what buyers say and what women 40+ say. Evidence and dose make up half the score, buyer ratings a quarter and women 40+ a quarter. Price is shown on every product, but it never changes a score.

1

How strong is the evidence?

We read the peer-reviewed studies on every active ingredient for that concern and count how many met our standard.

2

Is there enough in the bottle?

We check the strength in the formula against the strength that worked in the studies.

3

What do buyers say?

The overall star rating from each retailer we can read, one vote per site, with every site listed.

4

What do women 40+ say?

Women over 40 tell us what happened after weeks of use, not minutes.

Scored concern by concern

We score each claim separately, using the strongest ingredient for that concern at the strength in the bottle. The headline verdict comes from the up-to-three benefits the brand leads with. Other benefits the brand markets are scored too, and a stronger one lifts the overall score by 30% of the difference. Concerns the brand never claims are shown but never counted.

Where buyer ratings come from

We take the overall star rating each retailer shows and average them, one vote per site, so no single store drowns out the rest. A site counts once it has at least 25 reviews. We never copy or show individual reviews. A brand's own site is shown but not included in the average, because we can't verify how brands collect or filter their own reviews. Store ratings may include reviews from people who got the product free through sampling programs; we can't separate those out.

BluemercuryCos Bar · not readable yetGoop · not readable yetThe Detox Market · not readable yetNordstrom · not readable yetBergdorf Goodman · not readable yetBrand site · shown, not averagedCredo Beauty · not readable yetCult BeautyDermstoreLiberty LondonMeccaNeiman Marcus · not readable yetSaks Fifth Avenue · not readable yetSpace NKUlta BeautyViolet Grey · not readable yet

The verdicts

Worth It80 to 100

Strong evidence, a dose that matches, and buyers who stay.

Worth It If65 to 79

Good, with a condition. We tell you what it is.

Buy on Sale50 to 64

Does something, but not at full price.

Skip It0 to 49

The evidence, the dose or the buyers don't back the price.

How we grade an ingredient

Each active ingredient gets a grade for each concern. Clinical trials count most, expert consensus counts less, and marketing counts for nothing. We only credit an ingredient for improving something you already have: "helps prevent fine lines" tells you nothing about the lines you have now. Some brands feature extracts that aren't actives. For those we tell you what they're meant to do, taken only from official EU records (the European Commission's CosIng database, Cosmetics Europe's COSMILE database and the EU's Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety). We can't check how much is in the bottle or whether they work, so they don't count toward a score. Sunscreen filters are there to protect you from the sun, so we don't score them for lines, spots or firmness.

Clinical trialsProven

Backed by a positive systematic review or meta-analysis plus at least one controlled clinical trial, or by two or more controlled clinical trials applied to skin, at least one with 30+ people over 8+ weeks.

Clinical trialsStrong

Backed by a positive systematic review, by one controlled clinical trial with 30+ people over 8+ weeks, or by two or more smaller controlled trials.

Clinical trialsPromising

Positive results in peer-reviewed human studies that were small, uncontrolled, or tested it alongside other actives.

Expert consensusExpert-backed

Not yet backed by qualifying clinical trials, but recognized for this benefit by at least two independent authoritative sources: dermatology society guidance, peer-reviewed review articles, dermatology textbooks or regulatory reviews.

Expert consensusDerm-recommended

Recommended for this benefit by named dermatologists in reputable publications or by a single authoritative source, without clinical trials.

Early evidenceLab only

Only laboratory, animal or consumer-perception data so far; no human clinical evidence for this benefit.

Industry supportUnproven, some industry support

No qualifying clinical trials or expert consensus, but at least one named dermatologist or licensed esthetician says it improves this concern, in an independent publication or practice site. A quote that it only helps prevent the concern doesn't count. This is professional opinion, not proof that it works.

No supportUnproven

We searched the clinical literature and expert sources and found nothing that supports this benefit.

Evidence againstDoesn't work

Controlled trials or a meta-analysis found no benefit, regardless of popularity.

At home is not the same as in the chair

A 30% salicylic peel in a dermatologist's office and a 2% toner on your bathroom shelf are not the same treatment. So every ingredient gets two grades: one from studies at the strengths you can buy, and one from in-office peels and procedures.

Products are scored only on the at-home grade. In-office results can support an at-home grade only when dermatologists also recommend the at-home strength for that concern, and even then the grade stops at Expert-backed.

Cleansers and wash-off masks sit on your skin for a minute, not all day, so their ingredient evidence counts for less. And we score only what the brand actually promises on the box or product page, up to three claims.

Our rule

Commission never changes a score. Scores are set before we know whether a product pays us anything. Brands can't pay to be reviewed, featured or removed, and we will never own a skincare brand.