Concern
Dark circles
What the evidence says works, what it doesn't, and the products we've scored for it.
Earned its place
Caffeine
Promising
Hexapeptide-131 Aeea-Aeea Tripeptide-5
Promising
Oligopeptide-1 (Epidermal Growth Factor)
Promising
Peony root extract
Promising
Sodium ascorbyl phosphate (vitamin C)
Promising
Bakuchiol
Expert-backed
Hyaluronic acid
Expert-backed
Niacinamide (vitamin B3)
Expert-backed
Retinyl Acetate
Expert-backed
Algae extract
Derm-recommended
Hydroxypinacolone retinoate
Derm-recommended
Palmitoyl tripeptide-1
Derm-recommended
Tamarindus Indica Extract
Derm-recommended
Save your money
Ingredients marketed for this that haven't shown it works.
Acetyl tetrapeptide-5
Unproven
Allantoin
Unproven
Aloe vera leaf extract
Unproven
Ananas Sativus (Pineapple) Fruit Extract
Unproven
Bilberry fruit extract
Unproven
Caviar extract
Unproven
Dipeptide-2
Unproven
Ginseng root extract
Unproven
Hexapeptide-9
Unproven
Lactobacillus and purslane ferment extract
Unproven
Licorice root extract
Unproven
Matrixyl (palmitoyl pentapeptide-4)
Unproven
N-acetyl cysteine
Unproven
Nonapeptide-1
Unproven
Palmitoyl tetrapeptide-7
Unproven
Panthenol (provitamin B5)
Unproven
Pentapeptide-129 AEEA-AEEA tetrapeptide-10
Unproven
Retinol
Unproven
Retinyl palmitate
Unproven
sh-Oligopeptide-1
Unproven
Sodium acetylated hyaluronate
Unproven
Squalane
Unproven
Thiamidol
Unproven
White water lily flower extract
Unproven
Products for dark circles
64
111SKIN
Eye Lift Gel NAC Y2
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, dullness and radiance
- Fine lines and wrinkles95
- Dullness and radiance67
- Firmness and elasticity56
63
Natura Bissé
Diamond Cocoon Sheer Eye
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, hydration
- Fine lines and wrinkles89
- Hydration80
59
M-61
Hydraboost Eye Masks
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, hydration, texture and smoothness
- Fine lines and wrinkles94
- Hydration94
- Texture and smoothness74
58
111SKIN
Black Diamond Eye Cream
✕ Not proven for dullness and radiance
- Fine lines and wrinkles60
- Firmness and elasticity57
- Dullness and radiance32
57
Dr. Barbara Sturm
Super Anti-Aging Eye Cream
✓ Proven for barrier repair, redness, texture and smoothness, fine lines and wrinkles, dullness and radiance, firmness and elasticity
- Barrier repair76
- Redness73
- Texture and smoothness73
55
111SKIN
Celestial Black Diamond Eye Mask
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, hydration
- Fine lines and wrinkles81
- Hydration75
- Dullness and radiance64
50
SkinCeuticals
A.G.E. Advanced Eye Cream for Dark Circles
✓ Proven for hydration✕ Not proven for puffiness, dullness and radiance
- Hydration68
- Fine lines and wrinkles51
- Puffiness49
49
La Mer
The Eye Concentrate
✓ Proven for hydration, firmness and elasticity✕ Not proven for dark circles, fine lines and wrinkles
- Hydration79
- Firmness and elasticity70
- Fine lines and wrinkles42
48
Augustinus Bader
The Eye Patches
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, texture and smoothness, redness, firmness and elasticity, hydration✕ Not proven for dark circles
- Fine lines and wrinkles92
- Texture and smoothness92
- Redness74
41
RéVive
Intensité Volumizing Eye Cream
✕ Not proven for fine lines and wrinkles, dark circles, firmness and elasticity, puffiness
- Hydration63
- Fine lines and wrinkles43
- Firmness and elasticity41
41
BIOEFFECT
EGF Power Eye Cream
✕ Not proven for puffiness, dark circles, firmness and elasticity, dullness and radiance
- Barrier repair63
- Hydration63
- Texture and smoothness63
39
La Prairie
White Caviar Light Infusion Eye Serum
✓ Proven for fine lines and wrinkles, texture and smoothness✕ Not proven for dark circles, firmness and elasticity
- Fine lines and wrinkles95
- Texture and smoothness95
- Firmness and elasticity12
39
RéVive
Peau Magnifique Eye Concentrate
✕ Not proven for crepey skin, puffiness, dark circles, dullness and radiance
- Fine lines and wrinkles63
- Hydration59
- Firmness and elasticity50
38
Clé de Peau Beauté
Eye Contour Cream Supreme
✕ Not proven for dark circles, dullness and radiance, firmness and elasticity
- Hydration63
- Fine lines and wrinkles51
- Dullness and radiance36
37
111SKIN
Cryo De-Puffing Eye Mask
✕ Not proven for puffiness, dark circles, dullness and radiance, fine lines and wrinkles
- Puffiness40
- Dullness and radiance37
- Fine lines and wrinkles37
36
La Prairie
White Caviar Eye Extraordinaire
✓ Proven for dullness and radiance✕ Not proven for dark circles, firmness and elasticity
- Dullness and radiance94
- Hydration63
- Fine lines and wrinkles51
36
BIOEFFECT
Imprinting Eye Masks
✕ Not proven for dark circles, puffiness, dullness and radiance, firmness and elasticity
- Hydration60
- Texture and smoothness60
- Puffiness36
30
111SKIN
Cryo De-Puffing Facial Mask Set
✕ Not proven for puffiness, dark circles, fine lines and wrinkles, dullness and radiance, firmness and elasticity
- Hydration55
- Puffiness30
- Fine lines and wrinkles30
13
RéVive
Renewal Moisturizing Eye Cream
✕ Not proven for fine lines and wrinkles, dark circles, dullness and radiance, firmness and elasticity
- Hydration63
- Texture and smoothness53
- Fine lines and wrinkles14